User

Photo Critiques

from yellowhawk/Fred
About yellowhawk/Fred

All photos
321 photos
Leka
246 photos
Portfolio
75 photos

Photo critiques
421 critiques

Discussions
3 discussions

Journal entries
0 journal entries

Show newest first    Show most helpful first
Show oldest first    Show least helpful first

  Page 1234567891011...29Next >>

Click to view or critique
Lost in my shadows (2)
yellowgrey/Barbro (15,855)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on January 2, 2013 12:43:50 PM CST (1) Early critique

Your photo gives me a kind of sacral feeling, although I`m not a very religious person. Apart from that feeling, I don`t get the grip of this, or of you, hiding there behind something. But anything that makes me more religious, must be a good thing.... regards, Fred

Click to view or critique
Gaeta at dawn (3)
magnatti/Carlo (6,567)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on January 2, 2013 12:38:57 PM CST (2) Early critique

If it had been mine, I may have wanted to cut it a bit at bottom; not much, 1-2 centimeters. Otherwise fine, I like the clarity and sharply drawn contours of the buildings. Nice clouds, a good contrast to the darkness below. They seem to have been blurred a bit, but that`s fine with me. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
Between tow gardens (5)
tyafi/Talal (6,049)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 16, 2012 5:04:58 AM CST (1) Early critique

The door to some secret garden ? Could have been nicer. The grass inside the garden has turned blue, and I would have left out the part where we see the sky. The rest is not technically very good either, but your does have some atmosphere... regards, fred

Click to view or critique
Escher Ripples (9)
ektachrome/Francesco (13,110)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 16, 2012 5:00:02 AM CST (3)

Quite nice, but two things: I would have wanted the background to be calmer, the reflections in the water disturb med a bit. I would also have prefered the girl to be less aware of the photographer, as it is now her face reveals that she is very much aware of being photogrephed. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
Colorful Valve (7)
joehearst/Joseph (717)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 12, 2012 2:11:36 PM CST (2) Early critique

I see that you mention the reason for the crop being so tight. Still I think you could have avoided that, by cloning some color from the wall on both sides, for example. You have also cut the top, for some reason. Apart from this, I love the colours; old things like this, with paint flaking off, are really a find for photographers. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
This is how we roll. (3)
lizmartinez/Elizabeth (3)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 12, 2012 2:05:03 PM CST (0) Early critique

I would have preferred to see this in B/W, otherwise I like it somewhat. We see only the lower part of the child`s body ( a boy, probably), but with his feet firmly planted on the ground like this, I would guess that the rest of his body is quite proudly posed, a young child proud of his bike, and what he can do with it. So quite interesting, since it leaves much to o0ns`s imagination. regards, Fred

Click to view or critique
A Father's Joy (2)
michaelcastellano/Michael (71,626)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 12, 2012 9:48:26 AM CST (1) Early critique

Father and daughter having a great time together. The expression of joy and happiness and the girl`s face, and the proud face of her father, which is also expressing joy on his daughte`s behalf, are enough to earn your photo a couple of thumbs. I also find joy in the colours behind them, but I am a bit distracted by the dark thing just behind the father`s head ( another head ? ), and also by the yellow stuff at bottom of picture. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
You and I (3)
dakinpappu/Dakin Pappu (153)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 12, 2012 9:41:02 AM CST (2) Early critique

Sweet and romantic cliche, and as a cliche it functions enough to deserve one thumb. The horizon is tilting, however, and as far as cliches go, this is almost over the top. But Ok, I very reluctantly give you a tiny thumb. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
ethereal skaters (3)
vonprond/Franz (19,960)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 11, 2012 12:24:33 PM CST (2) Early critique

Original idea, but in my opinion not a particularly good idea. The way I would have preferred to see this shot is skaters more evenly distributed all over the ice, all fairly dark/ with good contrast against the white ice. And only ice, no sight of the `"geography" outside the skating rink. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
Road (3)
doginthefog/Alessandro (159)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 11, 2012 12:19:47 PM CST (3) Early critique

Like stepping into a hollywood movie I have seen innumerable times, therefore the scene, to me, lacks originality, although it is quite pretty. I see cars, so I think I`ll settle for "Paris, Texas". Anyone else who has seen it ? Like the way you have split up sky versus ground, though. Colours a bit lame.. regards, Fred

Click to view or critique
Stalking (19)
ncniceguy/Steve (8,546)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 11, 2012 10:09:49 AM CST (4) Early critique

smart. almost as if the branch mob to the left are crawling threateningly towards the lone branch-guy, who is putting his hands to surrender. No ? Well. at least thst was what I get out of thid photo, which is otherwise a pleasant sight, with its bluegreyish velvet look. Nice beach, nice horizon. regards, fred

Click to view or critique
Lonely (5)
royadinmuslim/Royadin (315)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 9, 2012 12:45:37 PM CST (3) Early critique

Weird little hut; not without a certain charm. You have placed it more or less "correctly" in the frame, and that seems to be an ok position. Bright light, which I would have subdued a bit, although you say the light is natural. Fair enough. regards, Fred

Click to view or critique
Rendez-vous Bundesplatz (4)
brunok/Bruno (188)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 7, 2012 9:45:50 AM CST (1) Early critique

I like it a lot. The blue illumination gives the building an almost eerie look, but also a fairy tale look, in other words, a perfect building for a dark and gloomy story.... The snow you mention looks more like rain to me, but anyhow; the effect is quite striking. regards, Fred

Click to view or critique
Aliens among us (6)
alesiaby/Alexandra (3,027)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 7, 2012 9:39:17 AM CST (2) Early critique

Very sweet situation and also very sweet baby-chimp. The cropping of the mother`s body seems a bit haphazard; I would at least have liked to see the whole hand, but apart from that this is a pleasure to look at, and the exposure looks perfect regards Fred

Click to view or critique
Old wooden church (8)
cajs/Caj (8,265)
Thumb-up    from yellowhawk/Fred (5,208) Send mail to this user on December 7, 2012 9:33:58 AM CST (5)

HDR , or at least that is what it looks like. To me the only redeeming feature of HDR are the details that result from this "technique". Such details are not always needed in a photo, but here, where the church and its architecture are the themes, it`s nice to see a sharp rendering. So plus for great sharpness that allows the viewers to study the church thoroughly, apart from that this is not my kind of photo. regards. Fred

  Page 1234567891011...29Next >>