Critiques
This photo currently has 2 conforming critiques.
If you write one of the first three conforming critiques for this photo, then you will receive three critique points every time another user rates your critique helpful.
Write a critique
If you find one of these critiques especially helpful--or especially unhelpful--then please take a moment to register your opinion by clicking one of the buttons to the right of the critique.
|
|
from moonpie/Eric (2,854) 
on January 28, 2004 1:11:16 PM CST
(1)
Great concept, superb composition, alhtough I wish the whole tire was in the frame. Darn shame its so grainy and borken up, the image should be smaller.
Reply
Show ratings
|
 |
|
| | |
|
|
from sheena/SheenaWilkie (13,039) 
on January 28, 2004 12:08:56 PM CST
(2)
I really like the idea here but it falls apart in the execution. I don't mind the car blurry as it is moving but the rest of the image must be sharp to work here. I also think if it were possible that having the flower not centered would make a stronger image. If it's possible I think you should shoot on this theme.
Reply
Show ratings
|
|
From k/Tomi (165)
on January 28, 2004 12:18:33 PM CST
Why didn't you rate it +1 (Overall good effort but in need of improvement)? -1 means uninteresting... It would look better if 25% would be cropped from right, I will do that and upload in 3 days. Adding saturation took off sharpness, the flower became a bit blurry. Asphalt looks bad (unreal etc) if too sharp.
Reply
|
|
|
From sheena/SheenaWilkie (13,039)
on January 28, 2004 12:22:12 PM CST
Hi Tomi, while I do find it interesting I cannot say it is an overall good effort because the execution is so poor.
Reply
|
|
|
From k/Tomi (165)
on January 28, 2004 12:44:01 PM CST
What would you have given to thumbnail? +1 or +2? Thumbnail doesn't show unsharpness, but it shows that flower is in center.. At least you selected it out of 50 thumbnails, and critiqued it. I don't know did you click it to tell how great it is, just a little cropping from right and it would be +2 (I noticed that you give only very little +3, so even +2 from you is harder to get than +3 from most of photosig users), but then noticed it is also unsharp, and was disappointed that actually it isn't such a good photo. Do not say that execution is poor, if only sharpness & cropping are poor. Because execution means also colors, saturation, brightness, contrast, zooming/distance, and maybe angle also.. This was taken in a hurry inside a car, before the light turned green.
Reply
|
|
|
From sheena/SheenaWilkie (13,039)
on January 28, 2004 12:48:41 PM CST
Hmm +1 as is, +2 if it wasn't centered and the tire was still in the frame.
Reply
|
|
|
From k/Tomi (165)
on January 28, 2004 12:54:55 PM CST
OK I try to upload +2 version of this, when I have the chance.
Reply
|
|
|
|
Comments
Comments are different from critiques. Comments carry no rating, you may write more than one comment per photo, and you may comment on your own photos. If you want to rate this photo, then you should write a critique instead.
Add a comment
There are no comments on this photo.
Return to photos
|
