Photos

Photo Critiques

All photos

Browse by f-stop
Browse by shutter speed
Browse by category
Browse by digital back/sensor
Browse by paper
Browse by scanner
Browse by filter
Browse by lens
Browse by camera
Browse by format
Browse by film
Browse by assignment
Browse by content advisory

Hot photos
Neglected photos
Random photos

Browse by user

Photo critiques

Submit a new photo

Show newest first    Show most helpful first
Show oldest first    Show least helpful first

<< PreviousPage 1...56789101112131415...200Next >>

Click to view or critique
Jubaini II (4) This item is new
jmrosz/Jan (224,773)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from arek0michalak/Arkadiusz (3,797) Send mail to this user on July 21, 2014 1:34:48 AM CDT (1) Early critique This item is new

Hi Jan. This is a very good portrait work girl. I like your idea with the sharp and blurred lines. Natural and colors and good use DOF in this composition. The big screw at the height of the eye model is to remove (in my opinion). Thanks for sharing.

Click to view or critique
Cheers (7)
katel/Kate (1,393)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from sparklingpearls/Carina (16) Send mail to this user on July 21, 2014 1:11:30 AM CDT (0) This item is new

The gold and the sparkles makes the glass look sophisticated and to drink champagne is really special I think you captured that. It would be good to make it as an invitation card for the new year celebration.

Click to view or critique
Clock tower (bw) (2) This item is new
fz8/Adam (9,504)
Thumb-up    from goodbokeh/Carl (4,207) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 11:37:31 PM CDT (3) Early critique This item is new

Nice optical illusion, Adam. The image has enough visual clues to help the viewer sort it out fairly quickly. Black and white works well for this image. But the conversion has resulted in sort of drab grays. You might be able to get more interesting effects in the clouds by playing with some filtering effects or even simple level adjustments. It looks like there is a lot there, if you can just let it out. -- Carl.

Click to view or critique
USS Ironsides (6) This item is new
ssal/Alex (34,967)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from goodbokeh/Carl (4,207) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 11:30:15 PM CDT (4) Early critique This item is new

Very nice sepia effect, Alex. Composition is nice. Backlighting gives an unusual effect on the spraying water, making it appear dark rather than white. Possible improvements -- "heal" out the white dots in the lower left, and a few towards the center (unless you intended those dots to enhance the antique effect of your photo). Consider toning down or eliminating the small craft on the far left of the image as they slightly distract. Overall, a very good "old" image. ...

Click to view or critique
A winter morning in the park (8) This item is new
siegfried5/Charlie (1,546)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from rondasue/Scott (3,911) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 11:08:37 PM CDT (4) Early critique This item is new

i really like your image. I agree about the banding. Otherwise gorgeous work. Marketable too i would think. Images like this on Photosig encourage me to return. thx

Click to view or critique
A winter morning in the park (8) This item is new
siegfried5/Charlie (1,546)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from fz8/Adam (9,504) This user is a Premium Member Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 11:07:24 PM CDT (5) Early critique This item is new

Love this picture, very well composed and very wintry too. I especially appreciate the gradual darkening of the sky which gives balance to the whole composition. The whites on the grasses seem a little exaggerated, makes one think of an infra-red photo, and of course I wish it were possible to remove the tree at near right :-) Thanks for sharing -Adam

Click to view or critique
A winter morning in the park (8) This item is new
siegfried5/Charlie (1,546)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from robertwallis/Robert (14,795) This user is a Premium Member This user is an Administrator Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 11:00:13 PM CDT (6) Early critique This item is new

I like the composition and balance of the image, and the tonal rendering looks good. I didn't notice it at first, but there is some ever so slight banding in the sky. If you have the file in RAW, go back and work on it again in 16 bit TIFF, and convert to jpeg at the end. Skies are notorious for banding when working on them in a jpeg workflow. You may be able to use the Heal tool by dragging a brush across each banding line.The other suggestion is to burn down the left...

Click to view or critique
A Sideways Glance (2) This item is new
dgpx/David (864)
Thumb-up    from perro/Perro (1,845) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 10:59:39 PM CDT (2) Early critique This item is new

Hi david, I saw your previous photos and are very good, however this photo need some improves, like the white balance, looks too blue ! The duck looks a little overexposed (on the right side). maybe a PS can help. Greetings Perro

Click to view or critique
A Sideways Glance (2) This item is new
dgpx/David (864)
Thumb-up    from rgordley/Rich (7,085) This user is a Premium Member Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 10:44:01 PM CDT (1) Early critique This item is new

The harsh lighting did you no favors. Blown highlights on the feathers in various places and complete loss of detail on the head in the shadow. You did manage a catch light in the eye however small. A polarizing filter might have toned down the reflections some. Shot early in the morning, at sunset or on an overcast day this would have been an entirely different and more pleasing image. Subject placement in the frame is good, but there is a LOT of green. I might consider...

Click to view or critique
A way to vineyard (3) This item is new
andpot/Andrzej (1,025)
Thumb-up    from siegfried5/Charlie (1,546) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 9:51:06 PM CDT (1) Early critique This item is new

Andrzej, The slant does not bother me too much, since most of the fence posts and the trees at right are straight. However, I felt the foreground and the bright segment of the right guardrail could be toned down. Thanks for sharing. -- Charlie

Click to view or critique
Holiday Pine Cone (3) This item is new
tigerpix/Tom (664)
Thumb-up    from goodbokeh/Carl (4,207) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 9:23:01 PM CDT (1) Early critique This item is new

Perhaps this will look better with text to balance the composition. As it stands, the pine cone is too centered in the image. Previous critic pointed out what looks like some jpeg artifacts. Those are also apparent at the bottom of the image in the "snow." Ahh, the "snow." It looks fake. I know, obtaining real snow in the northern hemisphere in July can be problematic, but the image looks too contrived. You might get a better result by placing your subjects, then...

Click to view or critique
Leviathan (4) This item is new
stanhope/Bob (1,485)
Thumb-up    from siegfried5/Charlie (1,546) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 9:22:28 PM CDT (4) Early critique This item is new

Bob, I like the idea of using small human figures to make the scale of the ship to stand out. I merely felt the crop on the left was a bit tight. Also, there are too much noise and dirt in the clouds and sky. Thanks for sharing. -- Charlie

Click to view or critique
A Mess o' Rectangles (6) This item is new
danfarkas/Daniel (4,425)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from siegfried5/Charlie (1,546) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 9:09:49 PM CDT (3) Early critique This item is new

Daniel, A very interesting piece, I like the boxes, roof, walls and rebar... playing games with my eyes and head. If any, I would tone down the lamp pole slightly and more for the roof of the lower right building. Thanks for sharing. -- Charlie

Click to view or critique
Jubaini II (4) This item is new
jmrosz/Jan (224,773)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from goodbokeh/Carl (4,207) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 9:06:53 PM CDT (2) Early critique This item is new

Great composition, Jan. The sharp, horizontal lines on the left foreground contrast with the background lines on the right. Model is well positioned, creating lots of dynamic effect. Can you bring up her right eye a little bit? It's in shadow, and appears to be the focal point of your image, but it's a little dark, especially when the iris of her right eye is compared to her left eye. Also, it appears that you have spent considerable effort in post-processing, and her...

Click to view or critique
ailleurs (4) This item is new
ektachrome/Francesco (14,304)
Thumb-up Thumb-up    from rondasue/Scott (3,911) Send mail to this user on July 20, 2014 8:48:12 PM CDT (1) Early critique This item is new

i love the lighting on her face. I looks like a Gekas mage in the light department. Agree that the crop is a little too tight for my taste. but not a ding really. More of an observation.

<< PreviousPage 1...56789101112131415...200Next >>