photoSIG Critique Standard

General Help
The Rules

General Help
Help on specific photoSIG features

photoSIG User Guide Wiki
Community standards and tips written by photoSIG users

Frequently Asked Questions

Tutorials on how to make the most of photoSIG

Listing of photographic (and SIGrelated) terms and definitions

In order to promote high-quality critiques, photoSIG only allows critiques that meet a certain standard to affect a photo's rating. Other critiques are saved and displayed, but have no effect on the photo's rating. A critique that conforms to the photoSIG critique standard (a "conforming" critique) will have colored thumbs, while a "non-conforming" critique will have hollow thumbs.

The photoSIG critique standards has four tests. A critique that passes all of these tests is deemed to conform to the standard.

Length: A conforming critique must be at least 15 unique correctly spelled words about the photograph.

Repetition: A conforming critique must be unique.

Frequency: A conforming critique must be either the first or second critique written by the critic for that particular photographer in the past seven days.

Average rating: A conforming critique must not be part of a pattern of very high ratings (which might indicate rating inflation) or very low ratings (which might indicate revenge rating). photoSIG expects an average rating of about one thumb-up per critique.

To see why a critique you have written does not conform, go to your mySG page, scroll down to the list of critiques you have given, and there will be one of the reasons above beside each critique that does not conform.

To avoid this entirely, use the preview link before submitting your critique. Ths function will let you know if your critique will conform or not and why, allowing you to adjust your critique.

Article Abstract
Article Category
Article Title
Content Advisory Definitions
Digital Back
Featured Photographer and Critic
Film Format
Message Are New Since
F-stop (Aperture)
HTML enabled
Internal Navigation
What Are Those Numbers?
Display All Sections on One Page
Photo Paper
Photo Filter
Photo Title
Private Article Option
Sample Help
Shutter Speed
Critique did not conform to standard (repetition)
Critique did not conform to standard (average rating)
Critique did not conform to standard (frequency)
Critique did not conform to standard (length)
HTML extended
photoSIG Critique Standard
What is the CVV2 or CID?
Withdraw or Delete a Photo
Copyright, Public Domain, Derivative Work
Why aren't you writing more critiques?