I am getting 'beat up'on this photo. I think it is because of it's overtly erotic nature. I am getting several thumbs down from the landscape and fine art shooters...I did not know that erotic photographs were unofficially taboo... If you are going to critique a photo maybe you should say what you feel is wrong rather than 'slam' it and run. I want to know whats up?

Read 516 times

This discussion is locked and will not accept any more replies.

From tbarney/Tom (2,948) on October 9, 2002 9:35:09 AM CDT you just said it yourself from the landscape & fine art shooters with no comments just empty thumbs. empty thumbs down are as useless as empty thumbs up. take the actual critiques of the TU people and use them

From pagreene/Paul A (11,184) on October 9, 2002 4:05:58 PM CDT Yep...you have a point there.

From 27866v1/Tom (51) on October 9, 2002 10:01:05 AM CDT Hi Paul, I just left a crit before I saw this thread. As Tom said, you will get the empty disapproval here for anything they decide "crosses the line". In all honesty I don't feel this shot is up to your standards and left my humble opinion of why. Has nothing to do with the red thumb club. Keep shooting and posting, screw 'em. lol

From pagreene/Paul A (11,184) on October 9, 2002 1:24:06 PM CDT thanks I appreciate the critique It helps...

Return to forum